Voters who tuned in to the Republican presidential debate on
CNBC last week were treated to an unabashed display of media bias as
interrogator after interrogator asked questions that were condescending,
inaccurate, belittling and rude.
Until, that is, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz used his allotted time
for one in a series of really stupid questions to go on the offensive rather
than meekly submit to the attacks. Following the example set by Cruz the
candidates rose up and called out the CNBC hacks for what they were. The
backlash against the network ranged from the audience booing the questioners to
the Republican National Committee severing its ties for further
"debates."
But you don't have to wait for another national political event
to see examples of media bias; it is all around us and in myriad formats.
Take for instance the race for First Selectman in
Stonington, Connecticut where former Congressman Rob Simmons is the Republican
candidate, facing incumbent Democrat George Crouse. Simmons, who has decided to
continue his lifetime commitment to public service by serving his hometown, was
endorsed by The Day newspaper as a man who can get things done locally and in
the state Capitol.
But after receiving the endorsement from the largest
newspaper in the area, Simmons was subjected to a scathing commentary from a
reader in the newspaper's digital edition, which lead off by accusing Simmons
of war crimes when he served in Vietnam a half century ago. Aside from the obvious
veteran bashing, the accusation is a rehashed attack that was launched at
Simmons by then incumbent Congressman Sam
Gejdenson back in 2000, when Simmons successfully challenged Gejdenson for
Connecticut's 2nd Congressional District seat.
At that time
Gejdenson initially claimed his campaign had no connection to the attack on
Simmons' credibility, but ultimately had to publicly apologize. Simmons served
two tours in Vietnam, and then returned as an operative
for the Central Intelligence Agency for an additional two years. He ultimately retired from the US Army Reserves as a Colonel in Military Intelligence.
Simmons has amassed
a distinguished military and political career, and has been a lecturer at Yale
University and the University of Connecticut as well. He was never accused of
war crimes in any forum outside of gutter politics, yet the libel that was aimed
at him remains in the commentary section of The Days digital edition.
Although most
reputable news outlets require that readers identify themselves and refrain
from launching unsubstantiated attacks on candidates in the last campaign days
leading up to the election, The Day appears to have made no effort to remove the
libelous commentary.
Apparently, racist,
sexist, profane or otherwise unsavory commentaries are scrubbed from the
website, but scurrilous libelous attacks on distinguished veterans are allowed
to stand. The commentary was signed by the pseudonym R. O. Thornhill, who the
Simmons campaign believes is actually a close adviser to the Crouse campaign.
Meanwhile, the town
of East Hampton, Connecticut, home of the late Gov. Bill O'Neill saw its own
version of media bias erupt this past week. The weekly newspaper Rivereast ran a
front-page article on the local school board chairman, a Democrat, deciding to
prohibit any town official from doing business with the school system.
This after the
chairman "discovered" that nearly 18 months ago, Republican Mark Philhower, a
member of the local Town Council who owns a Heating, Ventilating and Air
Conditioning firm called Tech Unlimited, had done some work for the schools.
The sudden announcement came in the form of a motion that was not part of the
regular agenda for last week's school board meeting, just a week before the
election.
The reason for the hasty action is, according
to the chairman, because he had only just discovered this egregious violation
of … something, although we're not sure exactly what … and had to act
immediately lest it be repeated.
The problem with the
coverage hits many buttons. First the chairman's point of view dominated much of the article, before Philhower's response is noted in the final graphs,
half of which were on the jump page. More important, after contacting
Philhower, I learned that two essential matters he had told the paper's editor were
left out.
First, he isn't the
only office holder who has done work for the town, especially for a department
over which he has no control. For instance, the owner of a school bus
company which has held millions of dollars worth of contracts with the town, also
served on the local zoning board. Philhower could not recall the local
democrats raising any issue about the propriety of this arrangement, especially
in the days just before an election.
Second, the work
Philhower did for the schools was of an urgent nature, amounted to about $6,000
and took place in February, March and May of 2014, mostly in the coldest part
of the winter. Both of these items should have been noted, and Philhower's
response should have been much higher in the story, rather than the supportive
but not especially detailed comments from school board Republicans.
Obviously, on-line
commentaries, libelous though they may be, and cheap political shots by small
town politicians don't rise to the level of national news personalities
attempting to sway a presidential election. But the principle is the same.
Our system of
government springs from local politics and the people who take the time to
serve on local boards and commissions deserve just as much consideration as
should be given to national level office seekers. The local media has
just as much responsibility to act ethically as the national and international
media should … regardless of the less than stellar example set by what is
called the Mainstream Media.
Otherwise, as
Philhower noted, the cheap attack on his credibility and his business, exemplifies
"why good people don't want to run for office."
Or, as Sen. Cruz said during CNBC's political debacle, ""The questions asked
in this debate illustrate why the American people don't trust the media."
0 comments:
Post a Comment